Beware “Artist” Shepard Fairey – A Comment on the Importance of Copyright & Contracts

In case you’re not familiar with “artist” Shepard Fairey, he originally came to prominence through his mass blanketing of stickers with an illustrated image of Andre the Giant accompanied by the word “Obey.” (I used to pick up stacks of those stickers in the early 90’s and put them on stuff ranging from trash cans to tripods.) Most recently, he achieved notoriety for stealing the image of Barak Obama from photographer Manny Garcia and then denying it in court.

In an interested turn of events, Fairey admitted that he not only stole the image, he also fabricated evidence and convinced witnesses to demonstrate that he didn’t. So now he not only lost his case against Garcia and the Associated Press, he’s facing possible jail time. Serves him right. Check out the story here.

And in other news, my photographer friend Dina Douglass was asked by Shepard Fairey to provide a portrait photo of a cancer survivor for use by Fairey in a charity auction. They agreed to some simple terms – which of course Fairey completely disregarded. The worst part of it is that though Fairey’s rendition of Dina’s painting was completely based upon her photo – she got no credit nor payment though the image was displayed in galleries around the world and even on the Nike website!

Note how the derivative artwork has Fairey’s signature on it. Because it is a derivative work from the original copyrighted image, the copyright does not actually belong to Fairey – it belongs to Dina Douglass. Many “artists,” designers and even photographers believe that if they change an image by XX percent, then the original copyright no longer applies. That is completely untrue. The copyright to any art that is based upon an original artwork will always rest with the creator of the original work – no matter how much the image is tweaked, illustrated, or composited with other images..

The other thing that I’ll point out is that a written agreement should be used in every single transaction with a client. Whether it’s a wedding contract or a simple commercial invoice with terms and conditions, every time we provide images to a client, the terms need to be in writing. A stock invoice accompanying one’s photograph in a case like this makes enforcing an agreement and a cash settlement much more straightforward. (A stock invoice is included in the Toolkit Commercial Contract Kit.)

Here’s the link to Dina’s full story as written on her blog.

John

Advertisements

About johnmireles

Photographer, writer, thinker, climber, outrigger canoeist, bad guitar player and even worse singer.
This entry was posted in Knowledge. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Beware “Artist” Shepard Fairey – A Comment on the Importance of Copyright & Contracts

  1. It’d be nice for the “original terms” to be outlined in your post. I don’t think it’s appropriate to essentially label someone a villain, especially in this specific circumstance.

  2. johnmireles says:

    Which specific instance we talking about? The one where he used Manny Garcia’s photo without permission? The one where he lied about it to the court and destroyed evidence about his lie? The part where he’s likely facing jail time? The instance where he agreed to provide credit to Dina Douglass for his derivative work and then blew her off? I’m kind of losing track here…

  3. Ellis says:

    He is a crook, and I carry no respect at all for Mr. Fairey. In a class at UCSD, I learned about him and had to research him and “his artwork,” quite a bit. Anyway, another artist, named Baxter Orr, had come out with some pieces that were a parody of Fairey’s most famous pieces. Mr. Fairey decided that it was a copyright violation and in turn threw a lawsuit threat against Mr. Orr. Hypocritical and disgraceful in my opinion by Mr. Fairey. Here is a link to more info http://animalnewyork.com/2008/04/shepard-fairey-threatens-to-sue-artist-for-obey-giant-parody/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s